dbt vs QuerySurge
Verdict: dbt scores 8.9/10 against 8.5/10 for QuerySurge on our data score for ETL testing tools.
dbt has a free plan; QuerySurge does not.
dbt leads on 2 checks and QuerySurge on 0; 4 are even, out of 6 checks (yes/no, price and seats) where we have data for both.
Choose dbt for analytics engineers testing transformations inside the warehouse. Choose QuerySurge for enterprise QA and data teams testing data warehouses, migrations and BI reports.
Scoreboard: 6 checks
| Check | dbt | QuerySurge |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Leads | |
| Free trial | Even | Even |
| Smaller seat minimum | Leads | |
| CI/CD integration | Even | Even |
| Scheduled test runs | Even | Even |
| Snowflake, Databricks and BigQuery support | Even | Even |
| Total | 2 | 0 |
At a glance
| dbt | QuerySurge | |
|---|---|---|
| Score | 8.9/10 (#2) | 8.5/10 (#3) |
| Best for | Analytics engineers testing transformations inside the warehouse | Enterprise QA and data teams testing data warehouses, migrations and BI reports |
| Free plan | Yes | No |
| Paid from (annual) | See vendor | $500.50/user/mo |
| Paid from (monthly) | $100/user/mo | — |
| Free trial | Starter plan free trial (length not stated) | 1-day hosted cloud trial (1 user), 15-day download trial (2 users), 45-day proof of concept |
| Minimum seats | 1 | 2 |
| Platforms | Cloud (SaaS), Self-hosted (open-source runtime) | On-premises, Private cloud (Azure, AWS, GCP and others), Azure and AWS marketplace (pay-as-you-go), Private cloud, Azure (pay-as-you-go), AWS (pay-as-you-go), Public cloud, AWS and Azure pay-as-you-go |
Features
| Tool | Score | No-code test creation | Source-to-target comparison | CI/CD integration | Scheduled test runs | Snowflake, Databricks and BigQuery support |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| dbt | 8.9/10 | Not confirmed | Not confirmed | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| QuerySurge | 8.5/10 | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
- Only QuerySurge confirms: No-code test creation, Source-to-target comparison.
Pros and cons
dbt
Pros- Free Developer plan (1 seat) and an Apache 2.0 open-source runtime
- Four generic data tests built in; any SQL query that returns failing rows can become a test
- Job scheduling and CI checks on GitHub and GitLab included from the free plan
- Adapters for Snowflake, Databricks and BigQuery among others
- Tests run inside one warehouse; comparing a separate source system with a target is not built in
- Tests are written in SQL and YAML rather than built in a no-code interface
- Starter costs $100 per user per month and is limited to 1 project; SSO needs Enterprise
QuerySurge
Pros- List prices are published on the vendor's site, including per-user and 5/10/25-user package prices
- Connects to 200+ data stores, including Snowflake, Databricks, BigQuery, Excel, Parquet, JSON and XML files
- BI Tester validates Power BI, Tableau, IBM Cognos, Strategy, Oracle BI and SAP BusinessObjects reports against source data
- Several trial options: 1-day hosted cloud trial, 15-day download trial and 45-day proof of concept
- Subscription per-user pricing starts at $6,006 per full user per year with a 2-user minimum
- BI Tester, Full API and Query Import/Export are paid add-ons on the smaller packages
- Customer-installed software (on-premises, private cloud, or pay-as-you-go Azure/AWS marketplace image) rather than a vendor-run SaaS
Frequently asked questions
How do dbt and QuerySurge compare on features and price?
dbt leads on 2 checks and QuerySurge on 0; 4 are even, out of 6 checks (yes/no, price and seats) where we have data for both.
Is dbt better than QuerySurge?
dbt scores 8.9/10 against 8.5/10 for QuerySurge on our data score for ETL testing tools. dbt is best for analytics engineers testing transformations inside the warehouse; QuerySurge is best for enterprise QA and data teams testing data warehouses, migrations and BI reports.
Which is cheaper, dbt or QuerySurge?
Check each vendor's pricing page; one of them does not publish an entry price.
Do dbt and QuerySurge have free plans?
dbt: yes. QuerySurge: no.
See the full ETL Testing Tools ranking for other options.
Sources
- dbt: official pricing page · dbt pricing page · dbt docs: data tests · dbt docs: unit tests · dbt docs: trusted adapters · dbt docs: installation overview
- QuerySurge: official pricing page · QuerySurge licensing & pricing · QuerySurge feature list · QuerySurge integrations · QuerySurge BI Tester · QuerySurge trial options · About RTTS · QuerySurge Power BI integration page · QuerySurge DevOps for Data page · QuerySurge FAQ